How to talk to a tenor (or any singer)…. some thoughts

I went to a pre-conference workshop (Pedagogy Saturday) on March 26 and attended a session with the above title. It was run by two teachers, one piano, one voice, and was intended to foster communication between singers and pianists, especially those who are young and not used to collaborating. Also some things about playing for students if you’re not really a pianist (hello!) or coaching singers if you’re not really a singer.

There were some good things about it – some things that reinforced what I am already doing in my own studio, some good ideas – but what bothered me was 
1. The title. Kind of reminded me of Ann Coulter’s How to talk to a liberal (if you must), which advises her readers to be deliberately combative and never see an opposing point of view as having any validity. (If you agree with her, don’t share it with me. I’d rather continue to think of anybody reading this as being gracious and open-minded.) It seemed to play up the “Us vs. Them” mindset or, more specifically, “Musician vs. Singer.” 
2. At the end, they addressed “what if the pianist is wrong?” by telling us that the singer should take the blame.  “I didn’t get that pitch – could you play that opening again?” 
That … is … so … girly. 
And it made me think that maybe I need to do some writing about collaboration – from a singer’s point of view, from a woman’s point of view, from a pedagogue’s point of view. How do we work together without becoming subordinate to our collaborator? Or making them feel like they are “wiggling their fingers in the background” while we take center stage? (Great perspective on that – see Ben Moore’s song “Content to be behind me,” about a diva who dismisses her pianist’s prodigious chops as being all for her.)
Hm. This is something to think about.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s